End of cages in animal husbandry with opposition from farmers: "Will drive thousands of farms off the market"

Breeding farm animals in cages has its days numbered. A few days ago, the European Parliament’s Agriculture Commission spoke in favor of its progressive ban after the publication of an impact assessment by the European Commission. This popular initiative has the support of almost 1.4 million signatures across the EU (more than 85,000 from Spain), demands that “put an end to the inhumane treatment of hundreds of millions of farm animals in the EU, kept in cages for most of their lives.”

Brussels welcomes the ‘End to the cage era’ (End the cage age), as this movement is called. In fact, with an overwhelming majority of MEPs -558 votes in favor and 37 against- this past June 10, the resolution went ahead in the European Parliament to end animal cages by 2027. With this broad support, the European Commission It should now legislate in this regard to review the rules on the protection of farm animals in order to prohibit this practice after a transitional period and a ‘species by species’ study that takes into account the characteristics of each of them.

The claim calls for a ban on the use of cages for raising laying hens, rabbits, pullets, breeder broilers, breeder laying hens and quail; farrowing boxes for sows; and stalls and individual pens for calves. In any case, MEPs consider that this project has to go ahead with the right support for farmers, who reject the project. For this, Brussels proposes the incorporation of training and advisory services, incentives and financial aid “before proceeding with a legislative change” in order not to suffer unfair competition from third countries that have “less strict” animal welfare standards and thus avoid relocation of local products.

GREEN COVENANT

Have been a total of 170 animal and environmental organizations those that have participated in this initiative, among them the ‘Animal Equality’ foundation, which calls for the revision of the 1998 Directive on the protection of farm animals in line with the philosophy already undertaken by the Commission on the Green Pact (Green Deal) and the ‘Farm to Table’ strategy.

Jo-Anne McAtrhur / Animal Equality

During the debate, jointly organized by the Committees on Agriculture and Petitions of the European Parliament (EP), the European Commissioner for Health, Stella Kyriakides, stressed that the large number of support achieved reflects how the use of cages in animal husbandry “is of great concern to European citizens.” In this sense, Janusz WojciechowskiCommissioner for Agriculture and Rural Development, assured during the debate on this initiative that EU agricultural subsidies (the CAP) and the Recovery Fund “can also be used in part to phase out cage farming and apply alternative methods” and He confirmed: “You have all the support of the European Commission to carry out this transformation.”

MEPs called on the European Commission to now draw up a European Union (EU) bill on “fair and sustainable” agriculture and to propose a review of existing EU rules on the protection of animals raised for farming. These legal changes will phase out the use of cages in EU animal husbandry, after an appropriate transition period, possibly by 2027. “Alternatives to cage farming exist and are being implemented successfully in several member states”, warned during the debate, where a majority of deputies showed their willingness to support a “more sustainable and less intensive” livestock.

DATA

According to the data of ‘Animal Equality’, in the EU every year more than 300 million animals in the EU “are forced to support a miserable life locked in cages, a cruel and completely unnecessary practice “, according to Silvia Barquero, president of this foundation. 92 million of them suffer from it in Spain, which is the country “with the largest number of animals locked up, a reality that in the XXI century must change, since European citizens demand animal welfare.” In his assessment, the cage system “is one of the cruelest practices in the livestock industry and completely incompatible with animal welfare.” The problem, he continues, is that most cages are “sterile, narrow and do not allow the animals to move freely; they are cruel and completely unnecessary.”

Barquero considers that, if Brussels finally approves the project, “it will be a historic day for animals”. “It all comes down to political will and some countries may make this transition faster than others, although it is clear that ending cages is something that it cannot be done overnight“. The head of the foundation considers that the maxim that governs industrial livestock is” to obtain the maximum benefit at the minimum cost and this logic, applied to animals, has devastating consequences for their well-being. “In this context, she assures that confining animals in cages “is directly linked to this view of animals as commodities because the economic benefits increase making the life of the animals a real hell: crammed in cages in which they can not develop any natural behavior.”

The alternative to cages proposed by these protective associations involves “the implementation of other systems, for example ground breeding for chickens -which is already the majority in Europe-, farm breeding for rabbits …”. He also explains that the transition to alternative systems to cages “is the responsibility of governments, companies, NGOs … and obviously must be accompanied and supported at all levels. It is not something that only farmers can do,” he reasons.

Winners

A diametrically different vision is provided by affected farmers, mainly those with small farms, who they will be expelled from the market -denounce- in favor of large industries, which will have more possibilities to reconvert their production processes. The agrarian organization COAG calls the initiative a “brutal reconversion in animal welfare, pushed by animalists, a few years after another similar one that ruined 4,000 farms” after warning what they consider to be “strict demands from activists who can drive farmers out of the market. small farmers, emptying Spain, promote industrial livestock, the only one with resources to face the reconversions, while increasing the price of meat to the consumer and multiplying the use of antibiotics. “

The organization recalls that the intensive livestock sector made a “beastly reconversion in 2013 and 2018”, imposed by community directives inspired in turn by demands of animal groups. The farms invested in all kinds of structures to improve the quality of life for the animals. For example, in the pig sector, costs were between 245 and 420 euros per breeder (There are more than 2.5 million copies in Spain). The average investment figure was approximately € 700 million.

In poultry farming, the 2018 conversion amounted to more than 200 million only in egg-producing farms. In addition, in some cases, such as pigs, the investments that were made had amortization periods that go up to 21 years. The balance was devastating: the number of farms in the sector has plummeted in the last decade. Thus, on January 1, 2013, according to COAG figures, there were 71,700 pig farms in Spain. At the end of 2020, the number barely reached 68,027 farms. From 2012 to 2020 the number of farms in Spain fell by 4,000 but the average census of animals in them rose from 319 to 427 animals. That is, the farms are larger, more industrial, and accommodate more animals in less space.

THE GARDENERS OF EUROPE

Aurelio Prez, a farmer and coordinator of COAG Castilla y Len, sees the news coming from Brussels with “enormous concern” and maintains that “this strategy does not seek to defend animals and end 68,000 farms in the coming years” while defending the system : “cages are necessary, essential for the management of livestock production and if they eliminate this we will not be able to bear it, and it cannot be allowed; it is a very serious problem”. For Prez, “they are going to turn us farmers and ranchers into the gardeners of Europe, that is the only reality” and he warns that “this good spirit that animalists proclaim will end up making the agricultural sector disappear because, from our experience, we already know that the necessary aid that they claim to promise us for the conversion will never arrive: we are tired of hearing about aid for improvements that never occur “.

The representative of COAG also denounces the risk of disappearance of what has come to be called the ‘Empty Spain’, the rural world: “We are already few, but with these attacks on our economy we will be less and less until we no longer there is none left, there is no population. ” “That speech that politicians are trying to sell us is completely false, they are just lies; they have abandoned us,” he denounces. “Although we are going to die fighting and when we do not have the strength we will have dignity.”


(function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(d.getElementById(id))return;js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src=”https://connect.facebook.net/es_ES/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.8&appId=279395918757488&status=true&cookie=true”;fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}(document,’script’,’facebook-jssdk’)); .

Disclaimer: If you need to update/edit/remove this news or article then please contact our support team Learn more

Leave a Reply